The regional health board that oversees St. Mary’s Hospital in Montreal says it will conduct an internal investigation into the end-of-life care the widow of a former Quebec premier received there, after her family said she suffered needlessly in her final days.
The family’s description of Andrée Simard’s treatment prompted Quebec Health Minister Christian Dubé to offer them his apologies “in my name and that of the network,” while the minister responsible for end-of-life care, Sonia Bélanger, said the responsible health board must “review practices at St. Mary’s Hospital so that a situation like this one never happens again.”
Simard, the widow of former premier Robert Bourassa, died last November, several days after being admitted to the hospital in Montreal’s west end.
Bourassa, who served as premier from 1970 to 1976 and from 1985 to 1994, oversaw the implementation of Quebec’s public health care system. He died in 1996.
The couple’s daughter, Michelle Bourassa, said her mother, a discrete woman, was admitted to the hospital with her maiden name and did not want to receive special treatment because of her status as the longtime premier’s widow.
Soon after Simard was admitted, it became clear he was going to die, Bourassa said in a lengthy letter to the hospital administration which he shared with the French newspaper, La Presse.
Denied a transfer to the palliative care unit, every request by the family to get appropriate care for Simard in her final hours turned into a pitched battle, Bourassa said.
“I must express to you all my indignation in the way she, as well as our family, were treated at St. Mary’s Hospital, especially by the staff on the eighth floor,” wrote Bourassa.
With their mother suffering and in pain, family members pleaded with staff to meet with an attending physician and to increase the intake of sedation Simard was receiving but were repeatedly turned away or ignored, she said.
“All we can do is try to process this nightmare and let our family’s wounds heal. But I can’t leave this story untold, because I believe that this establishment has some serious soul-searching to do.”
Simard was initially in a small room with another patient who had COVID-19, and there was barely enough room for visitors, Bourassa said. She said it was difficult to get staff to move her to a private room, even though she was entitled to it, according to the Act Respecting End-of-Life Care.
When her mother was moved a day later, Bourassa said, her new room had not been cleaned. It was littered with soiled medical equipment, including an empty syringe in the washroom.
The ensuing few days were increasingly tense, with Bourassa raising her voice at times and the staff threatening to remove her from her mother’s room, she said.
Over the course of her mother’s stay, she said, the family had several friends who were physicians and stopped by and assessed Simard’s situation because they felt abandoned by the hospital.
Bourassa said it was only after a family friend who was a former director of palliative care at the McGill University Health Center stepped in that her mother “finally began to receive the care to which she was entitled.”
“We had lost four precious days fighting,” Bourassa wrote. Her mother died a few hours later.
WATCH | MUHC palliative care director calls for better end-of-life care:
“I understand very well the issues of the hospital face: the lack of resources, the exhaustion of staff. But, on the eighth floor of St. Mary’s Hospital, it is not the lack of resources that is in question, but rather, the lack of compassion and respect for fundamental rights,” Bourassa wrote.
“The eighth floor of St. Mary’s Hospital is a place where humanity and dignity have been forgotten.”
Premier offers condolences, says situation is ‘unacceptable’
In a written statement, a spokesperson for the CIUSSS de l’Ouest-de-l’Île-de-Montréal — the regional health board that oversees the hospital — said “the details reported by the family don’t reflect the experience we wish to offer to our patients.”
“We have launched an internal investigation and our medical team will evaluate the file to ensure that care was provided according to best practices,” said Hélène Bergeron-Gamache.
“We are committed to implementing the necessary adjustments. The team is also available to discuss with the family if it wishes to.”
In a Friday morning tweet, Health Minister Dubé apologized to the family and said “health professionals must work together to offer humane care.”
Quebec Premier François Legault offered his condolences to the Bourassa family, describing the details that surfaced about Simard’s hospital stay as “unacceptable.”
“No one should have to live through that in their last moments,” Legault said in a statement Friday. “In Quebec, we’ve chosen to have humane and respectful end-of-life care.”
Not an isolated case: palliative expert
“I sincerely hope that our case is an isolated one,” Simard’s daughter said in her letter.
However, Dr. Justin Sanders, the director of palliative care at McGill University Health Centre, said he has seen similar situations arise daily, all across Quebec — ironically, the province where the concept of palliative care was born.
“Reading a letter like this is heart-breaking,” Sanders told CBC News. “Yet I wasn’t surprised.”
“This is a major gap in our medical education system,” said Sanders. He said while many hospitals have dedicated palliative-care units, where specialists and staff have the skills to take care of serious illness, “outside of those units, patients often receive care that is substandard to what we know is the gold standard.”
Bourassa said the whole situation left her “ashamed of our health system and very concerned about what the future holds for my fellow citizens.”
“I left the hospital in the early morning, after signing the necessary paperwork,” she wrote. “I was drained, sad, bitter and beside myself. All I wanted was to leave this awful place. I had just been deprived of an important, precious, serene and harmonious moment with the woman of my life, an exceptional woman, the wife of the man who was the father of Quebec health care. I could only think: what a shame!”
“For her, and contrary to what she would have liked because she always avoided controversy, I had no choice but to turn into a pitbull to protect her and her rights.”